A U.S. district justice decider has ruled which thirteen Motorola Mobility obvious claims associated to digital video have been shabby in a obvious chartering box brought by Microsoft.

Judge James Robart of U.S. District Court for a Western District of Washington ruled Wednesday which a obvious claims, associated to encoding as well as decoding a bitstream of digital video interpretation as well as a H.264 video codec customary have been not current since they aren’t sufficient scored equally to a specific invention detached from a ubiquitous role computer.

The claims have been scored equally to 3 Motorola patents.

Robart, in his ruling, postulated Microsoft’s ask for a outline visualisation opposite a patents. Microsoft filed a legal case opposite a Google-owned Motorola in Nov 2010, arguing which a mobile record association had reneged upon promises to have a video as well as a little WLAN patents accessible upon fair, reasonable, as well as non-discriminatory (FRAND) terms.

Motorola had argued which any Windows 7 OS as well as any duplicate of Internet Explorer 9 sole in a U.S. infringed a patents.

Robert didn’t buy Motorola’s invulnerability of a patents. “Microsoft provides estimable justification by approach of citations to technical journals as well as dictionaries which any of a examples is zero some-more than a mechanism thinly slice which contingency be automatic or written to perform a preferred function,” he wrote. “Hence … a disclosed examples of a decoder in a selection volume to ubiquitous role inclination automatic to perform a duty of a claimed equates to limitation, as well as therefore, have been uncelebrated from a ubiquitous role computer.”

A Google mouthpiece wasn’t rught away accessible for comment.

A judge’s statute upon chartering conditions for a Motorola patents is approaching soon.

Grant Gross covers record as well as telecom process in a U.S. supervision for The IDG News Service. Follow Grant upon Twitter during GrantGross. Grant’s e-mail residence is grant_gross@idg.com.

tags: aktualnosti.net, Case, claims, Digital Video Data, District Court Judge, E Mail Address, General Purpose Computer, Google, Grant, h, H 264, Idg News Service, Internet Explorer, invalidates, Judge, Judge James Robart, Logo, Microsoft, Microsoft Case, Microsoft Judge, Mobility, Motorola, patent, Patent Claims, Patent Licensing, Purpose Devices, Summary Judgment, Technical Journals, Telecom Policy, Twitter, Video Codec, Western District Of Washington